I ordered Shelly a "diamond" nose ring from Fresh Trends Body Jewelery, and although we had some mixups, I was really impressed by the lengths they went to get my nose ring order right, long after most companies would have given up. In the end, they replaced my cheap order with a real diamond nose ring! Plus they threw in what looks like either a belly button ring or tongue ring, for free.

So, give Fresh Trends Body Jewelery a go. They're good people.